Should You Buy Renters Insurance Through Your Property Manager or Leasing Agent?

Should You Buy Renters Insurance Through Your Property Manager or Leasing Agent?
As more large investment firms and professional property management companies get involved in rental properties, more are requiring tenants to secure renters’ insurance. Some have gone so far as to “suggest” or “recommend” a provider. The question is, should you get your renters’ insurance through your property manager? Are there any benefits to doing so?
Convenience
Clicking on a button on your leasing agent or property manager’s website to secure renters’ insurance may seem to be simple and convenient. But there may be a price to pay for that convenience. You may not get the coverage you deserve at a price that is comfortable for your budget. There are reasons you should secure renters’ insurance on your own.
Shopping for your own renters’ insurance policy keeps you in control. You decide the limits, coverage, and deductibles. You will also likely have more options to suit your budget.
When you make the decision on your renters’ insurance, you may qualify for a bundle discount with your auto insurance provider.
When you purchase your renters’ insurance individually, you are purchasing protection that works for you, not just your current landlord or property manager. This includes a variety of add-ons to cover personal electronic devices, coverage while traveling, and liability.
If you rent where you live, renters’ insurance is a good idea to protect your personal belongings and cover you for liability claims. Perhaps best of all, renters’ insurance is very affordable. We invite you to see just how affordable it can be for yourself.
If you are looking at renters’ insurance options, we encourage you to reach out to one of our independent insurance agents. They will connect with a network of companies to get you the coverage you deserve at a premium you can feel comfortable with. Securing renters’ insurance is prudent, but getting it through your landlord or property manager may not be. Contact our independent agents today.
Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder
Search All Blogs
Search All Blogs
Read More Blogs
Spring Sales and Safety: Managing Home Insurance Risks During Real Estate Season
Selling your home this May? Make sure your homeowners insurance is ready for the foot traffic of a spring open house.
The Mother of Mother’s Day: The Surprising History of Anna Jarvis
Did you know the founder of Mother’s Day ended up hating the holiday? Explore the fascinating, bittersweet history of our favorite May Sunday.
Small Business, Big Targets: Strengthening Your Cyber Defenses This May
Don’t be an easy target. This Small Business Week, learn how Cyber Liability insurance protects your shop from the “invisible” risks of 2026.
The Greatest Gift: Why Life Insurance is the Ultimate Act of Motherhood
This Mother’s Day, give the gift of certainty. Discover how modern life insurance provides “Living Benefits” that support moms through every stage of life.
Caring for the Caregivers: National Nurses Week and Professional Auto Discounts
Thank a nurse this week! Discover how healthcare professionals can access exclusive “Professional Discounts” on their auto insurance.
More Than a Bouquet: Protecting Mother’s Day Jewelry and Fine Gifts
Did Mom get something sparkly this year? Ensure her Mother’s Day gifts are properly insured with a specialized “Scheduled Personal Property” floater.
Ribbons, Roots, and Revelry: The Ancient Magic of May Day
Happy May Day! Discover the ancient origins of our favorite spring traditions and the surprising history behind the “Mayday” distress signal.
Big Dreams, Small Business: Celebrating Your Legacy During National Small Business Week
You are the heartbeat of your business. This Small Business Week, learn how to protect your legacy with Key Person insurance and smart continuity planning.
More Good Days, Together: How Mental Wellness Impacts Your Life Insurance in 2026
Your mental health matters as much as your physical health. Discover how prioritizing your wellness can actually improve your life insurance options this May.
The Greatest Two Minutes in Sports (and Liability): Kentucky Derby Driving Tips
Don’t let a “Derby Day” celebration lead to a claim. Discover the hidden insurance risks of carpooling and informal ridesharing this Saturday.