Is My Insurance Company Out to Screw Me?

Is My Insurance Company Out to Screw Me?

We have all heard the stories. “My insurance company doesn’t want to cover this” or “my insurance company will only pay me this much”. It certainly can be frustrating and even understandable why some people would ask “Is my insurance company out to screw me?”

First, it is helpful to understand that an insurance company is a business, and in many cases, a business with an obligation to their shareholders. But they also have an obligation to their customers and to the agents who represent them. Any insurance company that repeatedly “screws” their customers will not be in business very long, especially in these days of online reviews, social media and instant messaging.

It can also help to remember that not all claims are what they may seem to be. Some insureds view making a claim as if they hit the lottery. They want to get as much as possible. The intent of insurance, however, is not to leave the insured better off. It is to leave them whole. For this reason, the insurance company has adjusters to help verify and settle claims. Does every claim get settled in the precise manner an insured may have liked? No. Like any product or service, there will be those that may be less than satisfied. This is one of the reasons many choose an independent insurance agency.

Independent insurance agents have the ability to choose the companies whose products they want to represent. This allows them to select companies with the best reputations and track records. They can help you in the preparation of a claim, making sure all losses are properly documented. They can serve as your liaison with the insurance company in getting your claim settled fairly.

Our insurance agents, like the companies they represent, have a reputation to maintain. They earn their living helping to make sure our customers get the protection they need at affordable prices. They want to make sure any claims are settled appropriately and in accordance with the terms and obligations of the policy. Buying a policy digitally online may not provide this personal service.

If you would like to discuss your current policies or would like a quote on a new one, we would appreciate the opportunity to show you the difference working with an independent agent can make. Contact us today.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about
our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Read More Insurance Blogs

The Quiet Promise: Why Life Insurance is the Ultimate Act of Fatherhood

Father’s Day is about the legacy you leave. Learn how a well-structured life insurance policy is the most unselfish way to say “I’ve got you covered.”

A Legacy Beyond the Tie: Why Life Insurance is the Real Father’s Day MVP

Forget the socks. This Father’s Day, give the gift of absolute certainty. Discover why Life Insurance is the ultimate act of modern fatherhood.

The Ultimate Seatbelt: Why Life Insurance is the Core of National Safety Month

You wear a seatbelt and a helmet—why wouldn’t you wear a financial safety net? See how Life Insurance fits into your National Safety Month goals.

Beyond the Holiday: Using Memorial Day to Discuss Family Financial Security

This Memorial Day, honor the past by securing your family’s future. A guide to transitioning from military to private life insurance.

The Family Ladder: Structuring Life Insurance to Match Your Kids’ Milestones

Don’t overpay for life insurance. Discover how the “Laddering” strategy provides maximum protection for your kids while saving you thousands in premiums.

The Greatest Gift: Why Life Insurance is the Ultimate Act of Motherhood

This Mother’s Day, give the gift of certainty. Discover how modern life insurance provides “Living Benefits” that support moms through every stage of life.

More Good Days, Together: How Mental Wellness Impacts Your Life Insurance in 2026

Your mental health matters as much as your physical health. Discover how prioritizing your wellness can actually improve your life insurance options this May.

Rebuilding More Than Houses: Using Life Insurance to Fund Your Charitable Legacy

Inspired by National Rebuilding Day? Learn how to leave a lasting impact on your community by naming a charity as a life insurance beneficiary.

National Pet Day: Ensuring Your Life Insurance Includes a Plan for Your Pets

Who will care for your pet if you aren’t there? This National Pet Day, discover how to use Life Insurance to fund a Pet Trust and protect your best friend.

Spring Clean Your Beneficiaries: A New Quarter Checklist for Life Insurance

As we enter the second quarter of 2026, it’s time for a 5-minute life insurance audit. Ensure your coverage matches your family’s newest milestones.