You “Auto” Keep an Eye on It: Pros & Cons of Automatic Car Insurance Payments

You “Auto” Keep an Eye on It: Pros & Cons of Automatic Car Insurance Payments

Do you make your automobile insurance payments through a debit or credit card using an automatic payment system? “AutoPay”, as it is frequently called, is becoming increasing popular. In fact, recent surveys indicate that over a third of us, (35%) pay at least one bill through an auto pay system. There are some good reasons for this. There are also some things to be cautious about.

Here are some pros and cons of using auto pay for your car insurance and why you “auto” keep an eye on it.

Automatic Payment Pros

One of the most valuable reasons to sign up for automatic payment for your car insurance is that auto-pay usually comes with a discount. Making payments automatically can normally save a consumer the equivalent of a month’s payment or more over making individual payments “manually”.

Automatic payments eliminate the worry of forgetting a payment or making late payments. This is especially critical in automobile insurance. There is no need for postage or taking time each month to submit a payment online. For those ecologically minded, it saves on envelopes and fossil fuels used in mail trucks. Most automatic payment systems also allow you to select a payment date that is convenient for your budget.

Cons of Choosing Automatic Bill Pay

There are certainly benefits to making car insurance premium payments through an automatic bill payment system each month. There are, however, issues one should be aware of.

The biggest is perhaps, forgetting that an automatic payment will be made by check or credit card. This can lead to you exceeding your card’s limits, being overdrawn, or perhaps even having the payment rejected. This can create unneeded hassles and may cost you extra. Any savings achieved through auto-pay can quickly be spent through an overdraft fee.

Automatic payments are so seamless, drivers may often not pay attention to the amount of money they are being charged. Premiums may go up by only a dollar or two a month. Percentage-wise, however, those increases can be significant over time. Submitted payments manually keeps you better in touch with your expenses.

Auto-pay is just one way in which you can save money on your auto insurance. For others, please contact our independent insurance agents. They have the ability to shop multiple companies for the best rates for your circumstances. We look forward to assisting you.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Click Here

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Read More Blogs

Beyond the Holiday: Using Memorial Day to Discuss Family Financial Security

This Memorial Day, honor the past by securing your family’s future. A guide to transitioning from military to private life insurance.

he Great American Adventure: Preparing Your Policy for National Road Trip Day

Hitting the highway this Friday? Discover how to “road-trip proof” your auto insurance before you cross state lines for the long weekend.

Grilling Without Grief: Preventing Memorial Day Fire Claims

Firing up the grill this Monday? Make sure your Memorial Day BBQ doesn’t turn into a homeowners insurance claim with these essential safety tips.

Champagne and Sunshine: The Surprising Origins of the Mimosa

Happy National Mimosa Day! Discover how a Parisian hotel bartender and a film director created the world’s most popular breakfast cocktail.

National Mimosa Day: Managing “Social Host” Liability for Your Business Brunch

Serving bubbles this Saturday? Ensure your business is protected from the unique risks of “complimentary” alcohol service this National Mimosa Day.

The Family Ladder: Structuring Life Insurance to Match Your Kids’ Milestones

Don’t overpay for life insurance. Discover how the “Laddering” strategy provides maximum protection for your kids while saving you thousands in premiums.

Sharing the Lane: What Every Driver Needs to Know During National Bike to Work Week

It’s National Bike to Work Week! Learn how to share the road safely and how your auto insurance policy protects you even when you’re on two wheels.

Spring Sales and Safety: Managing Home Insurance Risks During Real Estate Season

Selling your home this May? Make sure your homeowners insurance is ready for the foot traffic of a spring open house.

The Mother of Mother’s Day: The Surprising History of Anna Jarvis

Did you know the founder of Mother’s Day ended up hating the holiday? Explore the fascinating, bittersweet history of our favorite May Sunday.

Small Business, Big Targets: Strengthening Your Cyber Defenses This May

Don’t be an easy target. This Small Business Week, learn how Cyber Liability insurance protects your shop from the “invisible” risks of 2026.