The 10% Rule: Should You Drop Your Comprehensive & Collision Insurance?

The 10% Rule: Should You Drop Your Comprehensive & Collision Insurance?

One of the most frequently asked questions about automobile insurance for those who own an older vehicle is when is it no longer economically wise to carry comprehensive collision coverage on that vehicle. For most, the 10% rule is a reasonable guideline. Here is how it works.

The 10% Rule Defined

The 10% rule is based on the premise that you should consider dropping your collision and comprehensive automobile insurance coverage when the cost of such coverage meets or exceeds 10% of the book value of the car. It sums that the MOST you can get to repair your vehicle is its book value so paying 10% or more for that protection provides diminishing returns.

Let’s take, for example, your vehicle has a book value of $5,000. Ten percent of this value would be $500. If the premium for the comprehensive collision coverage portion of your policy exceeds $500 annually, it is probably no longer a good value to maintain that coverage. You may be better off reducing coverage to just liability. Of course, it will depend on your tolerance for risks. You my also lose some other valuable protection by eliminating comprehensive collision coverage. It is best to ask your independent insurance agent how such a reduction will impact your coverage.

Why Minimum Coverage May Not Always Be Best

Understandably, most don’t want to pay any more than they have to for automobile insurance. This, like most things in life however, doesn’t necessarily mean you should get the cheapest or least expensive plan available. Just because states have minimum standards does not mean that may be sufficient for you. You may benefit considerably through the acquisition of under or uninsured motorist insurance, a rent-a-car provision when experiencing a loss of use or even higher minimums of overall coverage. This is particularly true for those who have more financial resources at risk.

One of the best solutions when you have questions about your automobile insurance coverage is to get an auto insurance review. If you prefer, your review can also include a quote from multiple insurance companies who compete for your business. This allows you to base your choice on value, not just price. Contact one of our independent insurance agents and get started today! Get the protection you need without overpaying for your automobile insurance.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in excerpt

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Click Here

Search All Blogs

Generic filters
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in excerpt

Home Sweet (and Secure) Home: The Dynamic Duo of Maintenance and Insurance

Beyond Bricks and Mortar: Unveiling the Secret Weapon of Homeownership (It’s Not What You Think!)

5 Hot Cities Millennials Are Flocking To (and Why They’re So Awesome)

Beyond the Usual: Top 5 Trending Cities Millennials Are Obsessed With (and Why You Should Be Too!)

From Ride-Sharing to Reality: 5 Billion-Dollar Ideas Born in the Last Decade

Billion-Dollar Babies: 5 Game-Changing Ideas Born in the Blink of an Eye

Unveiling the Different Players (and Why We’re Your Guide!)

Insurance Companies: Not All Created Equal! Find Your Perfect Match with Our Help

Beyond the Beep Beep: Unveiling the World of Supercars

Supercars: Where Luxury Meets Speed (and Million-Dollar Price Tags!)

Home Sweet Home, Protected Home: Why Upgrades Need Insurance Check-Ups

From She-Sheds to Sunrooms: How Home Improvements Impact Your Insurance Needs

Beyond Nicknames: The (Sometimes Bizarre) Tales of How American Cities Got Their Names

From Coin Flips to Greek Love: Unveiling the Hilarious Histories of City Names (and a Tip for Yours)

Small Biz Squad Unite! Why Independent Insurance Agents Are Your Secret Weapon

Ditch the Corporate Maze: Why Independent Insurance Agents Are Your Small Business Champions

Cracking the Code: Cash Value, Loan Value, Surrender Value – It’s All in the Life Insurance Policy!

Beyond the Death Benefit: Unlocking the Hidden Gems of Your Life Insurance Policy

Buckle Up for Safety: Are Cars Getting Smarter Than Crashes?

From Seatbelts to Superpowers: How Tech is Transforming Car Safety (and How You Can Benefit)