When It May Be Best NOT to File an Automobile Insurance Claim

When It May Be Best NOT to File an Automobile Insurance Claim
Your neighbor Bob may tell you one thing. Cousin Jeff may tell you another. It seems everybody has an opinion. When should you file an insurance claim with your automobile insurance company and when should you just try to take care of the consequences on your own?
The discussion usually centers around the potential rate increases you could see in your automobile insurance if you file a claim. There’s much more to consider, however. So, when should you file a claim and when may it be best to NOT file an automobile insurance claim?
You put a small dent in a car owned by someone else.
It can be tempting to settle this type of claim privately. The problem is you don’t know who you may be dealing with and they may request more funds in the future. You should file a claim in this situation.
You cause an accident that involves injuries.
When injuries are involved in an incident you caused, it is critical you contact your insurance company. This could eventually involve significant medical bills and you want the support of your insurer.
You cause significant damage to another vehicle.
Because there may be more damage than initially thought, you should always let your insurance company know if you cause an accident with serious damage.
You cause serious accidental damage to your own car.
You may want consider whether or not to make a claim under this circumstance based on your deductible and on the possibility your rates could go up upon renewal. Of course, if you just have liability coverage, there will be no need to file a claim.
You cause minor damage to your own car.
If you only have liability coverage or if damage is less than your deductible amount, there is no need to file a claim with your insurance company. Even if damage is slightly more than your deductible, you may be better off handling the situation on your own.
In reality, there are few circumstances when you will not want to notify your insurance company of an incident. This is particularly true if injuries are involved.
Do you have sufficient automobile insurance for your situation? We can help. Contact our independent insurance agents and get a no-obligation insurance review and quote. You may just find improved coverage at a more affordable price. Get more for your money when you contact us for your automobile insurance needs.
Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder
Search All Blogs
Search All Blogs
Read More Blogs
From Great Fires to Digital Twinning: The Story of Insurance Awareness Day
Why do we celebrate insurance on June 28? Discover the fiery history of this holiday and the world’s most “Bizarre” insurance policies.
Handshake Day: Why a “Gentleman’s Agreement” is a Professional Liability Risk
Happy Handshake Day! A handshake signifies trust, but a written contract signifies professional safety. Learn why “E&O” insurance loves the paper trail.
Beyond the Office: Why Your “Work” Life Insurance Isn’t Enough
Think you’re covered because of your job? Discover the “Group Life Trap” and why every family needs a private, portable life insurance policy in 2026.
National Insurance Awareness Day: The Mid-Year Auto Policy Audit
Happy National Insurance Awareness Day! Take five minutes this Sunday to ensure your car insurance matches your 2026 lifestyle and budget.
Sparklers and Statutes: Managing Homeowner Risk This 4th of July
Planning a backyard display? Learn how your homeowners insurance handles firework-related accidents and the “Illegal Act” exclusion you need to know about.
The Great Alignment: The Science and Secrets of the Summer Solstice
Happy Summer Solstice! Discover the “Great Alignment” of Stonehenge and the ancient traditions that celebrated the longest day of the year.
Celebrating Progress: Managing Your Business During the Juneteenth Holiday
Juneteenth is this Friday. Discover how to celebrate this historic holiday while ensuring your business stays compliant with holiday labor laws and social media standards.
The Quiet Promise: Why Life Insurance is the Ultimate Act of Fatherhood
Father’s Day is about the legacy you leave. Learn how a well-structured life insurance policy is the most unselfish way to say “I’ve got you covered.”
The Digital Witness: Why a Dashcam is the Best Father’s Day Gift for 2026
Looking for the perfect gift for Dad? A 4K dashcam isn’t just a gadget—it’s his best friend in an insurance claim. Discover the “Digital Witness” revolution.
The Longest Day of Liability: Managing Summer “Attractive Nuisances”
Summer is officially here this Sunday! Make sure your backyard “fun zone” doesn’t turn into a legal “hazard zone” with our guide to Attractive Nuisance liability.