Why is Auto Insurance for Teen Drivers SO Expensive?

Why is Auto Insurance for Teen Drivers SO Expensive?

Teenagers can be a real joy. They may be moody, contrary and they often become very good at pushing buttons. There is a good thing about them reaching their mid-teens however. While most of us are initially deeply concerned with them learning to drive, there’s a quick realization we will need to provide less “taxi service” for them. This means a little more freedom for both our teens and ourselves. Of course, that freedom comes at a cost. There is a little more stress and worry in our lives and OMG!!! What happened to those car insurance rates!!!

Why is Auto Insurance for Teen Drivers SO Expensive? The answer is statistics. Insurance is a statistics-driven industry and risks and rates are based on the numbers. For teens, many of these numbers aren’t good. This is largely due to inexperience which can only be cured by, well, experience.

The fact is 16-year olds have the highest crash rate of drivers of any age. One in five 16-year-old drivers will have an accident in that first year of driving. A third of the deaths that occurred to 16-19-year olds in 2010 was the result of a car accident. In spite of warnings about distracted driving, research shows 56% of teens have admitted talking on their cellphones while driving.

Now, you may say “Not my teenager” or “My teen knows better” but the insurance company has to look at the overall statistics. Teen drivers are inexperienced and that inexperience leads to an increase in accidents.

The good news is there is hope. If a young driver keeps his driving record clean, rates will decrease as he or she gains in driving experience. Money may also be saved if a student gets good grades. Attaching a driver monitoring device to a car can also result in lower rates. Before choosing a car for a teenager, check how a particular model will affect your overall insurance rates.

It can help to plan ahead. As a teen begins to move toward driving age, start considering what car they may drive and check to see how it will impact rates. Talk with your insurance agent about any potential discounts (like good grades) that they can be working on now. Most of all, talk to them about the dangers of distracted driving and set reasonable guidelines for automobile use. Practice safe driving habits yourself.

If you would like to discuss adding a teen driver to your insurance policy, contact us. We may not be able to help your teen become less contrary or moody, but we just may be able to minimize some of the sticker shock you will likely experience when pricing insurance for your new driver.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Click Here

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Read More Blogs

The Mid-Year Financial Audit: Securing Multi-Generational Wealth Before Q4

Don’t wait until December to review your financial plan. Discover why August is the perfect month to audit your life insurance and lock in generational security.

Beating the August Heat: Advanced Defensive Driving and Telematics Optimization

August brings brutal heat and heavy summer traffic. Learn how advanced defensive driving and telematics data can keep your commute safe and your insurance rates low.

Beyond the Block Party: Leveraging National Night Out for Elite Home Security and Insurance Savings

National Night Out is more than a neighborhood cookout—it’s your best defense against property crime and a pathway to lower insurance premiums.

The Lost Art of the Pen Pal: Celebrating Connection in a Digital World

Before the internet, there were pen pals. Discover the history of this beautiful tradition and why it’s making a small, intentional comeback.

National Intern Day: Mentorship, Risk Management, and Your Business

Bringing in new talent? Learn how to integrate interns into your business safely and minimize your liability exposure.

Financial Friendship: Why Your Agent is Your Best Asset

Who is looking out for your family’s financial future? Discover why a strong, transparent relationship with your life insurance agent is the ultimate long-term investment.

The Commuting Professional: How Your Driving Habits Affect Your Career Costs

Your driving record is more than a list of fines—it’s a professional asset. Learn how to optimize your commute for safety and savings.

The Friendly Host’s Insurance Guide: Protecting Your Property During Summer Gatherings

Love hosting friends? Ensure your home is as safe as it is welcoming with these essential liability protection tips.

Starlight and Screens: The Enduring Magic of the Drive-In Theater

From the 1950s to the 2020s, the drive-in theater remains one of America’s most beloved cultural icons. Discover the history behind the screen.

Beat the “Summer Doldrums”: Operational Resilience for the Hottest Month

Business feeling a little quiet? Use the late-summer “doldrums” to perform the insurance review that could save your company during the busy fall season.