Protecting Your House from the Terrors of Tenants

Protecting Your House from the Terrors of Tenants

Tenants can do an extraordinary amount of damage, and you don’t always know which tenants are going to be a chore. If you want to rent out your home, you need to protect it, first. Here’s how.

The Damage That Tenants Can Do

Have you ever had concrete poured down your drains? Copper wiring ripped out of your walls? Fish placed in your vents?

It might never happen to you… But it could.

Tenants can be malicious, especially if they’re being evicted. Tenants can also be negligent: a tenant can lead to thousands of dollars in plumbing expenses simply by flushing things they shouldn’t.

If you want to protect your investment, you need to be proactive.

First: Choose the Right Tenants

You can’t completely eliminate your risk by being picky, but it helps. Don’t skip calling references: it’s important. Run a credit check. Follow up with prior landlords. If a landlord refuses to say anything at all, well, that’s saying something. And make sure your tenants have renters insurance. You can (and should) require it as terms of your lease, so if anything does happen to your property, you can be compensated.

Get Landlord Insurance

Your regular homeowners policy doesn’t protect you from the risks involved with renting. You need a specific policy known as a landlords insurance policy. This is going to protect you from incidents in your home caused by tenants. But it will also protect you from associated issues, such as being without rental income while the concrete is being drilled out of your drains.

Like other home insurance properties, your landlords insurance will be based on the value of your home. So make sure you have a current appraisal and review your coverage limits.

Keep Up With Your Inspections

We get it: inspections are awkward and weird. Tenants hate them. Landlords hate them. But without regular tenant inspections, you’re not going to know about the above ground pool your tenants installed in your unfinished basement. At least, not until they’ve already moved out. Regular inspections are critical for catching problems before they become major issues. As long as you’re not too picky about cleanliness (who doesn’t have a few dirty dishes?), your tenants should be fine with them too.

Imagine the worst tenant horror story you’ve ever heard. Even that can be countered with the right insurance policy. Contact an independent insurance agent to get a quote today.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Click Here

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Read More Blogs

Take Your Kids to Work Day: Navigating the “Business Use” Insurance Gap

Bringing the kids along next Thursday? Make sure your car insurance covers your “mini-coworkers” if you’re using your vehicle for business errands.

Earth Day 2026: Is Your Eco-Friendly Upgrade Lowering Your Premium?

Celebrate Earth Day by saving green! Discover how eco-friendly home upgrades can earn you significant discounts on your homeowners insurance.

Why April 15th? The Surprising History of the Tax Deadline

Why do we owe the IRS by April 15th? Discover the history of Tax Day and some of the most bizarre tax facts in American history.

The Tax Day Crunch: Protecting Your Business from Professional Errors

Tax Day is almost here. Is your business protected against data breaches and professional errors during this high-stress week?

National Pet Day: Ensuring Your Life Insurance Includes a Plan for Your Pets

Who will care for your pet if you aren’t there? This National Pet Day, discover how to use Life Insurance to fund a Pet Trust and protect your best friend.

The Refund Reinvestment: Why April is the Best Time to Pay Your Auto Insurance in Full

Got a tax refund? Turn it into a 10% gain by paying your auto insurance in full this April. Discover the math behind the “Paid-in-Full” discount.

Clean House, Clear Mind: Addressing Hidden Liability Risks During Spring Cleaning

Is your spring cleaning creating a safety hazard? Learn how to protect your home and your guests as you declutter this April.

From French Fish to Spaghetti Trees: The Bizarre History of April Fools’ Day

Why do we play pranks on April 1st? Explore the centuries-old history and the most famous “fools” in world history.

Serious Fun: Managing Liability on International Fun at Work Day

Celebrating International Fun at Work Day this Wednesday? Learn how to boost morale without creating an insurance or HR headache.

Spring Clean Your Beneficiaries: A New Quarter Checklist for Life Insurance

As we enter the second quarter of 2026, it’s time for a 5-minute life insurance audit. Ensure your coverage matches your family’s newest milestones.