Do I Have to Contact My Insurance Company if an Accident is Not My Fault?

Do I Have to Contact My Insurance Company if an Accident is Not My Fault?

Some people have a reluctance to call their insurance company. They may feel such contact will initiate some mysterious spin of the insurance premium wheel and increase their rates. They may feel even so much as an inquiry may start some unstoppable force that will result in an increase in costs. Let us assure you neither will happen.

Now, it may be true that if you are involved in an at-fault accident, under certain conditions, it could result in a rate increase. This can be especially true if you were found extremely negligent.  However, that should never stop you from contacting your insurance company if you are involved in an accident. 

Let us be clear: You should contact your insurance company if you are involved in an accident with damage or injuries whether you are at fault or not.

There are several reasons for this. First, a vehicle that your insurance company insures and a driver it provides coverage to was in an accident. They need to know this. There may also be certain coverages in your policy, like towing or a rental car, that may be beneficial for you to use. Most importantly, however, is that your insurance company can make sure you get coverage from the other driver’s insurance policy and are defended in the event any claims are levied against you. These claims may not occur immediately. You should, however, notify your insurance company in writing, making note that you are not filing a claim, but just notifying them of the incident. This will alert them should future claims be made.  

Contrary to continuing legends, insurance companies are not looking for reasons to raise your premiums. They are actually trying to maintain and grow their customer base through responsive service. They can’t provide that if they are not properly notified.

As an independent insurance agency, we work on your behalf. We work as your ambassador when we are researching initial price quotes and we work as your liaison in a claim. We are also confident in working with companies with a history of responsive and responsible service. Get the coverage and the service you deserve. Contact us for a no-cost, no-obligation auto insurance review today.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Click Here

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Read More Blogs

The Paperless Legacy: Managing Your Digital Assets and Insurance Logins this Spring

Can your family find your policy? Use this first week of Spring to organize your digital insurance documents and legacy passwords.

Don’t Rely on Luck: Navigating the High-Risk Roads of St. Patrick’s Day 2026

Luck won’t save your insurance rates. Stay safe this Tuesday with our guide to St. Patrick’s Day road safety and liability protection.

Spring has Sprung: A 5-Point Insurance Protection Checklist for the Vernal Equinox

Welcome the first day of Spring with a home protection plan. Discover the five key areas to inspect this week to keep your home insurance claims-free.

Snakes, Shamrocks, and History: Getting Ready for St. Patrick’s Day

Why do we wear green? Explore the fascinating true story of St. Patrick and get ready for the celebrations coming next week!

The High Cost of a Typo: Celebrating National Proofreading Day with Errors & Omissions Insurance

One typo can cost a fortune. Celebrate National Proofreading Day by ensuring your business is protected by Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance.

Spring Into Health: Why Your March Physical is the Best Time to Lock in Life Insurance Rates

Getting your Spring physical? Learn how your health stats determine your life insurance premiums and how to “ladder” your coverage for better value.

Losing an Hour, Increasing the Risk: Navigating Drowsy Driving After Daylight Saving Time

Watch out for the “Sleepy Monday” surge. Discover why the week after March 8th is statistically more dangerous for drivers and how to stay covered.

Spring Forward, Check Upward: The Essential DST Smoke Alarm and Carbon Monoxide Audit

It’s time to change your clocks and your batteries. Learn how maintaining your smoke alarms protects your family and your home insurance standing.

Marching Into Spring: The History and Harmony of National Marching Band Day

It’s time to “March Forth!” Celebrate the music and movement of National Marching Band Day this Wednesday, March 4th.

Appreciating Your Team Safely: Managing Liability for Employee Appreciation Day

Celebrating your team this Friday? A quick guide to ensuring your Employee Appreciation Day events are covered under your business insurance.