When Should I Drop Comprehensive Coverage on My Older Car?

When Should I Drop Comprehensive Coverage on My Older Car?

Carrying comprehensive automobile insurance coverage on a newer car can be a very smart idea. If your vehicle is financed, comprehensive coverage may even be required by your lender. When, however, should you begin to question the value of paying for comprehensive coverage on an old beater?

As mentioned, if you have a loan on your vehicle, you may not have a choice. Your bank or lender may ask that you carry comprehensive coverage on your car for as long as they hold the note, or title, to the vehicle. This protects their interests in the event your car is severely damaged.

The more challenging question comes when you no longer owe money on your vehicle. You may be paying a significant amount to cover it not just for liability but for damages it sustains in an accident or if it were to be stolen. You may even be hoping it will be stolen.

The point is, value for the coverage you receive may not warrant the higher premiums you may be paying. This can be particularly true if you have a high deductible.

Generally, many experts believe you should not pay for comprehensive and collision coverage if your premiums exceed about 10% of your vehicle’s value.

In a real-life example, let’s say your vehicle’s actual cash value is $5,000. If you have a $500 deductible on your comprehensive coverage, the MOST you could recover if your car were “totaled” in an accident or never recovered if stolen is $4,500. Most experts would suggest if your premium to carry comprehensive coverage on that vehicle is $450 annually, (10% of the maximum $4500 the insurance company would pay) you should consider dropping your comprehensive coverage.

Of course, you need to keep in mind all states mandate minimum coverage for liability insurance, so we are not suggesting dropping insurance entirely. There may come a point, however, when it is financially prudent to consider not carrying comprehensive coverage on an older car.

Of course, your situation may vary according to your personal finances and your ability to withstand a significant personal monetary loss. If you have any questions, we certainly invite you to contact us. Our independent agents can not only help in your decision to the amount of automobile insurance you should carry but can even help you find providers who may offer better rates for your specific situation. Contact us. Let us help you pay less for more.


Do you have questions about your insurance? Find an insurance agent near you with our Agent Finder

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Buzz Your
Insurance Agent

Search for a local agent with our agent finder map.

Agent Finder

Want to learn more about our blog writer?

Read more about KayLynn's background.

Click Here

Search All Blogs

Generic filters

Read More Blogs

October Operations: Protecting Your Business for the Rest of the Year

A guide to fall business insurance review and risk management for entrepreneurs.

The October Promise: A Time to Secure Your Family’s Future

A thoughtful guide to understanding life insurance and securing your family’s future.

October Driving Prep: Get Your Car and Your Policy Ready for Fall

A guide to preparing your car and auto insurance for the fall season.

The October Home Check-Up: Securing Your Home for the Fall Season

A guide to fall home maintenance and home insurance review for the month of October.

The Wanderer’s Playbook: The Art of Traveling on a Budget

A practical guide to finding and saving money on travel adventures.

The Entrepreneur’s Toolkit: From Startup to Success, Insuring Every Step of the Journey

A phase-by-phase guide for entrepreneurs on the essential business insurance policies they need.

Beyond a Payout: How Life Insurance is a Living Financial Tool

A guide to how life insurance can be a living financial tool, with a focus on its cash value component.

The Driver’s Playbook: How to Maximize Your Auto Insurance Benefits

A playbook for drivers, revealing key policy benefits and strategies to get the most from your auto insurance.

Beyond the Big House: Uncovering the Hidden Value in Home Insurance

A deep dive into the valuable but often overlooked components of a home insurance policy.

The Thrill of the Grill: A Masterclass in BBQ Perfection

An ultimate guide to mastering grilling and barbecue, with tips, techniques, and delicious recipes.